Personal reviews

Secrets St. James Montego Bay Review: What Went Wrong

Our honest Secrets St. James Montego Bay review: cold room service, a 90-minute wait for water, a sleepy casino and a gorgeous beach. Who it suits.

The wedding gazebo on the rock breakwater at Secrets St. James Montego Bay, over clear turquoise water

The short version

  • Our score: 3 out of 5.
  • Worth it? For the beach and the grounds, yes. For the service, not at these prices.
  • Book it if you want a calm, pretty beach and you’ll eat in the restaurants.
  • Skip it if you live on room service, you want your privacy respected, or you want a proper casino.
  • Our stay: 12 nights, 12 to 24 September 2019, Junior Suite Ocean View, two adults, all-inclusive.
  • Open now? No. It has been closed since Hurricane Melissa in October 2025; Hyatt says early 2027, reportedly as part of a merged “Secrets Montego Bay” (checked 5 November 2026).

Gorgeous beach. Slow, careless service. Bring patience, and your own water.

Our verdict
Watch “Secrets St. James Montego Bay: our honest review (video)” on YouTube
Our video review: room service, the water, the privacy light, the food, the bars and the casino.

We stayed at Secrets St. James in Montego Bay, Jamaica, for twelve nights in September 2019. Let’s get the nice part out of the way: it is a beautiful resort. The beach, the grounds and the room were all lovely, and plenty of people come home raving about it.

This review is about everything else. The room service that never came, the bottle of water that took an hour and a half, the privacy light that nobody respected, the breakfast, and the casino that time forgot. We stayed a while ago, so we have checked what has changed since (a lot, thanks to a hurricane) and dated anything that might move.

Is Secrets St. James open? Hurricane Melissa and the 2027 reopening

No. Secrets St. James has been closed since Hurricane Melissa, a Category 5 storm, hit western Jamaica on 28 October 2025. Its twin next door, Secrets Wild Orchid, closed too.

Hyatt, which runs the resort, first said it would reopen on 1 November 2026. In April 2026 it pushed that back to the first quarter of 2027, saying it would fully restore the resorts and improve them while it was at it: refreshed rooms, updated public spaces, new restaurants and new infrastructure, rather than a partial reopening.

Tour operators are more cautious than that: some aren’t selling stays until the spring or summer of 2027. Our advice is not to book anything non-refundable until Hyatt names a firm date, and to check the UK government’s Jamaica travel advice before you go.

It may not come back under this name. On 19 September 2026 the Jamaica Information Service, the government’s news agency, reported that Hyatt will merge Secrets St. James and Secrets Wild Orchid into one resort of about 700 rooms called Secrets Montego Bay, fully renovated, with the promenade restaurants back on new menus and a reopening in the first half of 2027. We haven’t seen Hyatt announce the name itself yet.

Recent news, newest first:

  • 19 September 2026: the Jamaica Information Service reported the merger into “Secrets Montego Bay”, reopening in the first half of 2027.
  • September 2026: Jamaica’s tourism minister said airline seats to the island were down 22% on 2025, with about 70% of hotel rooms back open ten months after the storm.
  • Autumn 2026: tour operators list first stays from early to mid-2027, depending on who you book with; Hyatt still says the first quarter of 2027.
  • 29 July 2026: Jamaica issued its first ever casino licence, to the Princess Grand resort at Green Island in Hanover. (Hotel “casinos” like the one at Secrets have only ever been slot-machine lounges.)
  • March 2026: Sangster International Airport was back to about 358,000 passengers a month.
  • 12 to 15 April 2026: Hyatt pushed the reopening of seven Jamaican resorts, including both Secrets, to the first quarter of 2027, to restore and upgrade them.
  • 16 December 2025: Hyatt extended the closure to 1 November 2026; guests could rebook elsewhere or cancel free.
  • Late November 2025: Montego Bay’s Hip Strip, Doctor’s Cave Beach and Margaritaville were open again; Dunn’s River Falls reopened on 11 November.
  • 1 November 2025: Sangster International Airport reopened to commercial flights after storm damage.
  • 28 October 2025: Hurricane Melissa, a Category 5 storm, crossed western Jamaica; its eyewall passed over Montego Bay. Hyatt suspended all eight of its Montego Bay-area resorts.

Last checked: 5 November 2026. We’ll update this when the date moves.

Satellite image of Hurricane Melissa covering the whole of Jamaica on 28 October 2025
Hurricane Melissa over Jamaica on 28 October 2025, from the GOES-19 satellite. Photo: CSU/CIRA and NOAA, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
Palm trees around a roundabout on the Montego Freeport peninsula in March 2026
Montego Freeport, the peninsula the resort sits on, in March 2026. Photo: Goga504, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Secrets St. James at a glance

  • What it is: an adults-only (18 and over), all-inclusive resort. Secrets calls its version “Unlimited-Luxury”: drinks, restaurants without reservations, 24-hour room service, and taxes and tips included.
  • Size: 350 suites on five floors. It opened in 2010. If the reported merger with Wild Orchid goes ahead, it reopens as part of a 700-room “Secrets Montego Bay”.
  • Where: on the tip of the Freeport peninsula, west of downtown Montego Bay, about 20 minutes by road from Sangster International Airport (MBJ).
  • Its twin: Secrets Wild Orchid is next door. Guests of either can use both resorts’ restaurants, bars and pools.
  • Who runs it: Hyatt, as part of the Hyatt Inclusive Collection, since Hyatt bought AMResorts’ parent company in November 2021. When we stayed, it was AMResorts.
  • Check-in and out: 3pm and noon.
  • What others think: about 10,400 reviews on TripAdvisor averaging 4.3 to 4.5 out of 5, and 8.3 out of 10 on Booking.com (November 2026). Its lowest TripAdvisor score is for value. So we are in the grumpy minority, but not alone: recent reviews before the storm mention long waits for room service, and one from October 2025 describes calling four times and waiting three hours for bottled water. Sound familiar?
Aerial view of a waterfront building with red roofs among green trees on the water in Montego Bay
Montego Bay from above. Not the resort. Stock photo: Ranteen Dixon, Pexels licence.

Our room: the Junior Suite Ocean View

Our Junior Suite Ocean View was about 52 square metres (559 square feet): a four-poster king bed, a sofa and coffee table, a little table for two, a ceiling fan, and sliding doors onto a balcony. Every suite has a minibar restocked daily, a big TV, a double vanity, and two clever features we’ll come back to: a privacy light and the Secrets Box, a hatch in the wall for room service deliveries.

The room itself was lovely, and we have no complaints about it, which for us is saying something. The “ocean view” was a view of the sea past the palm trees, the gardens and the pool. Call it an ocean glimpse. If you want to wake up to water and nothing else, you need an Ocean Front room.

The four-poster king bed in a Junior Suite Ocean View at Secrets St. James Montego Bay
Our photo, September 2019: our Junior Suite Ocean View on the first night.
The sofa, coffee table, dining table and balcony doors in a Junior Suite Ocean View at Secrets St. James
Our photo, September 2019: the lounge end of the suite, with the balcony beyond.
The view from a Junior Suite Ocean View balcony at Secrets St. James at dusk: palm trees, gardens and the sea beyond
Our photo, September 2019: the “ocean view” from our balcony at dusk. It’s there, behind the trees.

Which room should you book?

Hyatt’s own “from” prices, per person per night for two adults sharing, based on September low season. They were set before the hurricane, so treat them as a guide: expect more from mid-December to mid-April, and perhaps more again after the rebuild.

  • Junior Suite Garden View: from US$217.50 per person (about US$435 a night for two). The cheapest room.
  • Junior Suite Ocean View (ours): from US$244.50 per person (about US$489 a night).
  • Junior Suite Ocean Front: from US$267.50 per person (about US$535 a night).
  • Preferred Club Junior Suite Ocean View: from US$307.50 per person (about US$615 a night). Adds the club lounge, private check-in, a separate club pool, a soaking tub on the balcony and use of Breathless Montego Bay next door.
  • Preferred Club Premium Junior Suite Beach Front and Junior Suite Ocean View Swim Out: from US$361.50 and US$378.50 per person. These are the cheapest rooms that come with a butler.
  • Master Suites and the Presidential Suite: from US$476.50 to US$836 per person.

Our pick, if we went back: skip the Ocean View. For about US$46 a night more, Ocean Front gets you the view you thought you were paying for. And if room service matters to you, look hard at the club rooms with a butler: the resort’s own list of what the butler does includes “speeding up room-service orders”. Which tells you everything.

UK tour operators such as Kuoni sell packages here too; compare them with booking direct once the reopening date is firm.

Room service: the tablet that never sent our order

Room service is included at Secrets St. James and runs around the clock. In 2019 you ordered it on a tablet in the room, which is where our trouble started.

Order one. We placed it on the tablet and waited. And waited. Two hours later we found out it had never gone through. The tablet hadn’t said a word.

Order two. We ordered again. An hour and a half later we had both fallen asleep waiting for it.

It got better after that, in the sense that food did arrive. It just often arrived cold, and something from the order was usually missing: a side, a sauce, a drink. When you are paying for an all-inclusive, the whole point is that you don’t have to think about any of this.

Four covered room service plates and a bottle of fizz in an ice bucket on the bed in a Secrets St. James suite
Our photo, September 2019: a late-night room service order, under the lids. Lovely when it turns up.
A room service spread laid out on the bed at Secrets St. James: pizza, nachos, quesadillas, a burger and fries, and fried cheese sticks
Our photo, September 2019: the menu is long: pizza, nachos, quesadillas, burgers. None of it improves with an hour in a corridor.
Two plates of hash browns delivered by room service at Secrets St. James
Our photo, September 2019: hash browns, ordered off the menu for breakfast. They were happy to make them. They arrived cold.

What we would do differently: order by phone, not the tablet, and ask when it will arrive. If nothing has come in 45 minutes, ring again. Order things that travel (pizza, sandwiches, salads) rather than anything fried.

The minibar

The minibar is included and, on paper, restocked every day with soft drinks, juice, bottled water and beer (at Wild Orchid next door, guests have found Red Stripe, Coca-Cola drinks and local Bigga sodas in theirs). There are no spirits in the standard minibar: for those you go to a bar, or ring room service.

Preferred Club rooms get what the resort calls an “upgraded” minibar, but it doesn’t say what that means, and we haven’t found anyone who says it includes spirits. The club lounge does pour better liquor, and if you have a butler they will fill a cooler with whatever you like.

Nothing in the minibar is charged, so there is no bill shock here. The catch is the restock: if it doesn’t happen, you are back to ringing for water (see below).

Ninety minutes for a bottle of water

We asked for bottled water to be brought to the room. An hour later we were told it was on its way. It arrived after more than an hour and a half.

It is a small thing. But in Jamaica in September you want water now, not after a feature film, and when a resort can’t get a bottle of water to a room it makes you wonder about everything else. We weren’t unlucky, either: a review from October 2025 describes calling four times and waiting three hours for bottled water. The minibar is meant to be restocked with water every day: check it is, and take a few bottles back from the bar each evening so you never have to ask.

The privacy light nobody respected

This one still annoys us. Every suite has two clever things: a privacy light you switch on from inside, and the Secrets Box, a little two-door cupboard in the wall so room service can leave a tray without coming in or seeing you. It is a great idea, and on paper it means you are never disturbed.

One day we had the privacy light on and the Do Not Disturb sign on the door. Room service knocked anyway. Then knocked again. Four times in all. We weren’t dressed, so we shouted through the door to use the box. He did, and slammed both of its doors shut on the way out.

For an adults-only resort that sells itself to couples and honeymooners, privacy isn’t a nice extra. It is the product.

Breakfast: the buffet or nothing

In 2019 we found three ways to have breakfast: the World Café buffet, the 24-hour coffee shop (Coco Café) with its sandwiches, pastries and snacks, or room service. We weren’t offered a sit-down breakfast with a menu. Room service breakfast had about five options. We asked for hash browns, which weren’t on it; they said yes, and they came cold (see above).

The croissants deserve a line of their own. They tasted like something designed in a lab to resemble a croissant from a distance.

In fairness: the resort’s 2024 fact sheet lists an à la carte breakfast at Bordeaux, its French restaurant, from 8 to 10:30am. If you want eggs cooked to order at a table, ask about it when you arrive, and ask again after the 2027 reopening, when the restaurants are being reworked.

Room service breakfast plates on the bed at Secrets St. James: hash browns, bacon, sausages, fruit and pastries
Our photo, September 2019: room service breakfast. About five things to choose from.

The restaurants: the better bit

Dinner in the sit-down restaurants was a step up from room service, if only because the food hadn’t been on a long walk first. The fajitas even arrived sizzling, which after a week of lukewarm trays felt like an event.

Before the storm, the two Secrets resorts shared ten restaurants, most of them along a promenade between the two: the World Café buffet, Bordeaux (French), Oceana (by the sea), Portofino (Italian), Himitsu (pan-Asian, with teppanyaki), El Patio (Mexican), Blue Mountain (Jamaican), the Seaside Grill, the Barefoot Grill for burgers and snacks, and Coco Café. No reservations, but not every restaurant opens every night, and most want “casual elegance” at dinner: long trousers and a collared shirt for men, no flip-flops. Hyatt says there will be new restaurants when it reopens, so expect some of this list to change.

Steak fajitas on a sizzling skillet with tortillas, guacamole, sour cream and cheese at a Secrets St. James restaurant
Our photo, September 2019: fajitas at dinner. Hot! On purpose!
A plate of jerk chicken with rice and peas and fried plantain
Jamaican-style jerk chicken, rice and peas and fried plantain: what Blue Mountain’s menu was built around. Not taken at the resort. Stock photo: Snappr, Pexels licence.
A calamari and leaf salad starter in a dimly lit restaurant at Secrets St. James
Our photo, September 2019: dinner is lit for romance, not for photos.

The bars

Drinks are included, top-shelf spirits too, and there is Red Stripe on tap. Before the storm the two Secrets resorts shared nine bars and lounges (hours from the resort’s 2024 fact sheet):

  • Barracuda: open-air bar, 10am to 6pm.
  • Sugar Reef and Manatees: the two swim-up bars, 10am to 6pm.
  • Marlin Bar: 10am to 6pm.
  • Rendezvous: the lobby bar, with a piano, 10am to 11pm.
  • The Lounge: piano lounge, 10am to 1am.
  • Piano Bar: Cuban-themed, 5:30pm to 1am.
  • Desires: sports bar and late-night club with a DJ, 10pm to 2am.
  • Revive: the spa’s juice bar, 8am to 8pm.

Notice the pattern: the pool and beach bars shut at 6pm, so evening drinks mean the lobby, the lounges or Desires. Expect the list to change after the 2027 rebuild.

A pint of lager and a glass of fizz on the bar, with Red Stripe and Red Stripe Light taps behind, at Secrets St. James
Our photo, September 2019: Red Stripe on tap at one of the bars.
An orange tropical cocktail with a pineapple wedge on a wooden table
The kind of rum cocktail the pool bars pour all day. A generic photo, not taken at the resort. Stock photo: Nano Erdozain, Pexels licence.

The beach and grounds: what you are really paying for

Here is the bit we can’t complain about. The beach is gorgeous: soft sand, shade under the palms, proper daybeds with cushions, and calm, clear water inside the breakwaters. The grounds are kept beautifully, the big pool sits right by the sea, and the little gazebo out on the rocks is the photo everyone takes (us included). There are three wedding gazebos in all, two of them out over the water.

In the evenings there are shows; the night we filmed, it was fire dancers and drums.

Daybeds with purple cushions under palm trees and umbrellas on the sand at Secrets St. James, with the sea behind
Our photo, September 2019: the beach. This is the part that earns the stars.
A terrace with wicker chairs, flowers and tall palm trees looking across the bay to green hills, at Secrets St. James
Our photo, September 2019: a morning view across the bay. Almost makes up for the croissants.
The main pool at Secrets St. James Montego Bay with the sea and umbrellas behind it
Our photo, September 2019: the pool, with the sea just beyond.
A fire dancing show on the stage at night at Secrets St. James, with guests watching
Our photo, September 2019: a still from our video of the evening fire show.
Palm trees and a thatched umbrella silhouetted against an orange and blue sunset over the bay at Secrets St. James
Our photo, September 2019: sunset from the beach. Free, on time, never cold.

The casino at Secrets St. James

Does Secrets St. James have a casino? Sort of. It has a gaming lounge: a room of slot machines on the promenade it shares with Wild Orchid, open 24 hours, and not included in the price. There are no table games and no croupiers. (In Jamaica, a real casino with live dealers is only allowed inside a very large licensed resort, and the country’s first casino licence was only issued in July 2026.)

When we went in 2019, the gardens had a sign pointing to “Gaming: Jay Vegas”. Don’t picture Las Vegas. Picture a small, quiet room of slot machines with red stools and a carpet that has seen things.

The machines were old. We filmed one: a 10-cent “Leprechaun’s Gold” game with pots of gold, rainbows and graphics from another decade, the kind of thing you’d expect at a seaside arcade. And some of the time there was nobody working there at all, which by then was a theme. Other guests have said the same: you can’t cash out at the machine, so you need an attendant to pay you, and if there isn’t one, you wait.

Whether the gaming lounge comes back after the rebuild hasn’t been announced.

A sign in the gardens of Secrets St. James reading Gaming, Jay Vegas, with an arrow
Our photo, September 2019: the sign to the gaming room. The sign is the most Vegas thing about it.
A row of slot machines with red stools in the small gaming lounge at Secrets St. James Montego Bay
Our photo, September 2019: the gaming lounge. Not a croupier in sight.

Secrets St. James or Secrets Wild Orchid?

They are two halves of the same complex, 350 suites each, both adults-only, joined by the promenade with most of the restaurants, the theatre, the bars and the gaming lounge. Guests of either can use both. St. James is pitched as the quieter one, with British colonial decor; Wild Orchid as the livelier one, with a more Jamaican feel.

In practice you will eat in the same restaurants and drink in the same bars, so book whichever has the room you want at the better price for your dates. Preferred Club guests at St. James can also use Breathless Montego Bay, the separate adults-only resort next door, which is closed for repairs too.

This question may answer itself: the Jamaica Information Service reported in September 2026 that the two will reopen as one resort, Secrets Montego Bay. If that happens, there is nothing left to choose between.

A wooden gazebo on a rock breakwater over turquoise water at Secrets Wild Orchid, Montego Bay
one of the breakwater gazebos at Secrets Wild Orchid next door, in 2014. Photo: Scott Goss, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Next door, in 2019: Hard Rock Cafe Montego Bay

When we had had enough, there was the Hard Rock Cafe Montego Bay, which sat right next to the resort on the same Freeport site, a short walk away.

Sport on every screen, a milkshake the size of a small child and a sharing platter that could feed a family. We were on an all-inclusive and still walked next door to pay for lunch, more than once. That tells you something.

It has closed since. The Hard Rock Cafe shut in March 2020, at the start of the pandemic, and never reopened. Today the nearest change of scene is the Hip Strip, officially Jimmy Cliff Boulevard, a taxi ride away across town, with Margaritaville and Doctor’s Cave Beach (US$8 to get in). Both were open again by the end of 2025.

Inside the Hard Rock Cafe Montego Bay: booths, a long bar and sport on the screens
Our photo, September 2019: Hard Rock Cafe Montego Bay, next door to the resort, before it closed.
A Hard Rock Cafe sharing platter: spinach dip, onion rings, chicken wings, potato skins and tortilla chips, with dips
Our photo, September 2019: the sharing platter. We were on an all-inclusive. We paid for this anyway.
A huge chocolate milkshake topped with cream and cookies at Hard Rock Cafe Montego Bay
Our photo, September 2019: a milkshake that needed its own seat.

What costs extra

Most things are included: food, drinks (top-shelf spirits too), room service, the minibar, Wi-Fi, non-motorised water sports (kayaks, small sailboats, guided snorkelling, a scuba taster in the pool), the gym, daytime activities and the evening shows. These cost extra (prices from the resort’s 2024 fact sheet and booking sites; most aren’t published, so ask):

  • Spa treatments: no price list published; expect roughly US$120 to US$200 a treatment. The spa is 15,000 sq ft and open 8am to 8pm. Guests say the staff sell hard.
  • A butler: free from the Preferred Club Swim Out and Beach Front rooms up; in other rooms you can pay for one (price on request).
  • A Preferred Club upgrade on arrival: price on request.
  • Motorised water sports: parasailing, banana boat, water skiing, tubing, deep-sea fishing, glass-bottom boat and boat tours.
  • The catamaran: the resort has its own, “additional costs may apply”; independent Montego Bay catamaran snorkel trips sell for about US$67 to US$140 a person.
  • Excursions: Dunn’s River Falls tours from Montego Bay about US$70 to US$120 a person; Martha Brae bamboo rafting about US$130 to US$160 a person.
  • Golf at five nearby courses, horse riding, a private romantic dinner and bottled wine from the list.
  • Packages: Honeymoon Bliss US$1,449 to US$1,999; the Wedding in Paradise package US$1,299 to US$1,799 (free with seven nights in a Preferred Club Junior Suite Ocean View or above); vow renewals US$699 to US$949.
  • The gaming lounge: your own money, obviously.
  • Airport transfers: not included; private transfers from about US$40 a car each way.
  • A dog: US$65 a night (under 10kg, certain rooms only).
  • Shops, the salon, car hire and laundry.
  • Not a guest? A day pass (through ResortPass, for both Secrets resorts, 10am to 5pm) was from £89 a person before the storm.

Taxes, tips and the small print

  • Taxes and tips are included in Secrets’ all-inclusive rate. There is no resort fee.
  • Room tax: Jamaica charges a Guest Accommodation Room Tax of US$4 per room per night at hotels this size. Since August 2025 some Montego Bay all-inclusives have added it to the bill at check-out instead of including it; check whether your booking includes it.
  • Sales tax: hotel stays carry 10% GCT (inside the all-inclusive price). The Jamaican government has proposed raising it to 15% from April 2027, which would push prices up.
  • Arrival and departure: Jamaica’s US$20 Tourism Enhancement Fee and its departure tax are built into your air fare.
  • Tips: included, so nobody should expect more. Extra tips are welcome; take some small US dollar notes.
  • Money: prices are in US dollars; Visa, Mastercard and Amex are accepted; the ATM gives US dollars (fees may apply).
  • Age: adults only, 18 and over.
  • Dress code: “casual” by day (long shorts are fine, cover-ups over swimwear, no sleeveless shirts for men); “casual elegance” at most dinners (long trousers and collared shirts for men, no flip-flops).
  • Check-in and out: 3pm and noon. Late check-out is on request, with no published price.
  • Not clothing optional: we found no nude or topless area at either Secrets resort.
  • Drones are banned without the general manager’s written permission.

Montego Bay in September: weather and hurricane season

We went in September, which is the cheap end of the year for a reason. It is hot and humid, it is the middle of hurricane season, and when it rains, it really rains. We had bright blue mornings, and at least one afternoon downpour that emptied the terrace in seconds.

The numbers back us up. September in Montego Bay averages 33°C highs, 135mm of rain and 14 wet days; October is wetter still. The Atlantic hurricane season runs from 1 June to 30 November and peaks from August to October. Melissa arrived on 28 October.

Heavy rain falling on an empty terrace with wicker sofas and palm trees at Secrets St. James in September
Our photo, September 2019: a still from our video of a September afternoon. The terrace emptied fast.
Grey skies and rain over the beach, loungers and thatched umbrellas at Secrets St. James
Our photo, September 2019: the same afternoon, looking out to sea.

The best time to go to Montego Bay

  • Best weather: February to April, the driest months (about 7 to 9 rainy days a month), with highs around 30°C.
  • Most expensive: mid-December to mid-April, especially Christmas, New Year and Easter.
  • Cheapest: late spring to autumn, which is also the wettest and, from June, hurricane season.
  • Our pick: early December (hurricane season is over, peak prices haven’t started) or the second half of April (after Easter, still dry).
A palm tree and beach umbrellas on a Montego Bay beach at sunset, framed by trees
A Montego Bay beach at sunset. Not the resort. Stock photo: Vladimir Kalugin, Pexels licence.

Getting there

  • From the UK: Virgin Atlantic flies from London Heathrow every day and from Manchester; TUI flies from Gatwick, Manchester and Birmingham. It is about 10 hours out and a little less back. British Airways flies to Kingston, not Montego Bay. Virgin was showing Heathrow returns from £592 for January 2027 (checked 5 November 2026).
  • From the US: non-stops from about 20 cities, on American, Delta, United, Southwest and JetBlue among others.
  • From the airport: Sangster International (MBJ) is about 20 minutes away by road. Licensed taxis have a desk outside customs, and private transfers are advertised from about US$40 a car each way.
  • Documents (UK passports): no visa for stays of up to 90 days; fill in Jamaica’s C5 immigration and customs form online before you fly.
  • Plugs: US-style sockets at 110 volts. Bring an adapter, and check your hairdryer copes with 110V.
The terminal at Sangster International Airport, Montego Bay, seen from the car park
Sangster International Airport, Montego Bay, in 2024. Photo: Cuban Boy, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Tips if you book Secrets St. James

  • Order room service by phone, ask when it will arrive, and chase it at 45 minutes.
  • Keep water in the room: check the minibar each day and take bottles back from the bar.
  • Use the privacy light and hang a note on the door: “Please use the Secrets Box”.
  • If room service and quiet matter, price up the club rooms with a butler before you book the cheapest room.
  • Pack long trousers and a collared shirt for dinner.
  • Tips are included. Extra tips are welcome but not expected; take some small US dollar notes anyway.
  • Recent guests mention a holiday-club sales pitch at check-in that runs far longer than promised. A polite “no thanks” saves a morning.
  • Don’t go for the casino.

Secrets St. James FAQ

Is Secrets St. James Montego Bay open? No. It has been closed since Hurricane Melissa on 28 October 2025. Hyatt says it will reopen in the first quarter of 2027, and some tour operators aren’t selling stays until mid-2027. (Checked 5 November 2026.)

Is Secrets St. James being renamed? Jamaica’s government news agency reported in September 2026 that it will reopen merged with Wild Orchid as one resort, Secrets Montego Bay, in the first half of 2027. Hyatt hadn’t announced the name itself when we checked.

Is Secrets St. James worth it? For the beach and grounds, yes. If you rely on room service or care about privacy, only in a club room with a butler, in our experience.

Does Secrets St. James have a casino? A small gaming lounge of slot machines, shared with Wild Orchid, open 24 hours and paid for separately. There are no table games. In 2019 the machines were old and it was sometimes unstaffed.

Is room service free at Secrets St. James? Yes, it is included and runs 24 hours, delivered through the Secrets Box. Our orders in 2019 took up to two hours, and one never arrived.

Is breakfast buffet-only? In 2019 we only found the World Café buffet, the coffee shop and room service. The resort’s 2024 fact sheet also lists an à la carte breakfast at Bordeaux, so ask.

Can Secrets St. James guests use Secrets Wild Orchid? Yes. The two share a promenade of restaurants and bars, and guests can use both.

Is the Preferred Club worth it? It costs from about US$63 per person per night more than an Ocean View room and adds a lounge, private check-in, a club pool and use of Breathless next door. The butler only comes with the Swim Out, Beach Front and bigger suites.

Which is the best room at Secrets St. James? For the view, a Junior Suite Ocean Front. For service, a Preferred Club Swim Out or Beach Front with a butler.

How far is Secrets St. James from Montego Bay airport? About 20 minutes by road.

Do you tip at Secrets St. James? Tips are included in the price. Extra tips are welcome but optional.

Is Secrets St. James adults-only? Yes, 18 and over.

Is September a good time to go to Montego Bay? It is cheap, but hot, wet and the middle of hurricane season. February to April is drier.

Is there still a Hard Rock Cafe in Montego Bay? No. The one next to the Secrets resorts closed in March 2020.

Can you earn World of Hyatt points at Secrets St. James? Yes. It is in World of Hyatt, so you earn points on paid stays and can spend them on free nights; Hyatt’s all-inclusive award chart runs from 12,000 points a night at its cheapest resorts.

Is there anything within walking distance? Not really. The resort sits on the Freeport peninsula; Wild Orchid is a five-minute walk along the promenade, but the Hip Strip is about 5km away by taxi and there is no free shuttle.

Is Montego Bay safe for tourists? The UK Foreign Office says crime is high in Jamaica but gang violence is mostly in inner-city areas; tourist areas are usually unaffected, robbery is the main risk, and you should use licensed taxis with a blue JTB sticker. Read its Jamaica safety advice before you go.

Is the Wi-Fi free? Yes, it is included.

Is Secrets St. James clothing optional? No. We found no nude or topless area at either Secrets resort.

Can you buy a day pass? Before the storm, yes: ResortPass sold day passes for both Secrets resorts from £89 a person, 10am to 5pm, adults only.

Photo credits

Photos marked “Our photo” are ours, from September 2019. Stills from our own videos are marked the same way. The others are free stock or free-licence photos, none of them taken at the resort: from Wikimedia Commons, Hurricane Melissa Crosses Jamaica by CSU/CIRA and NOAA (public domain), Montego Freeport 2026 by Goga504 (CC BY-SA 4.0), Paradise by Scott Goss (CC BY 3.0) and Sangster International Airport by Cuban Boy (CC0); from Pexels (Pexels licence), Montego Bay from above by Ranteen Dixon, a Montego Bay sunset by Vladimir Kalugin, jerk chicken by Snappr and a tropical cocktail by Nano Erdozain. We don’t use the hotel’s own photos.