Iceland

Reykjavik EDITION Review: Our Debit Card Check-in Standoff

We had paid in full, but the Reykjavik EDITION would not check us in on debit cards. Our honest October 2024 review: the room, rooftop bar and fees.

The hotel lounge in the morning, a black fireplace hanging over a live fire, leather and white armchairs and a green-lit wall

The short version

  • Our score: 2 out of 5.
  • Worth it? Not for us. The hotel itself is nice, super modern and right on the harbour, and the rooftop bar was lively. But we had paid in full and were still refused at check-in without a credit card, and the room’s lighting was awful. We would never return.
  • Our trip: one night, Saturday 19 to Sunday 20 October 2024, a couple, in a Superior King Room with Courtyard View: ISK 110,616 (about £615), paid in full on Booking.com when we booked.
  • Still the same? Yes. It is open, its Booking.com page still asks for a credit card at check-in, and the nightly resort fee has gone up from ISK 5,950 to ISK 7,000 (checked 15 November 2026).

The hotel itself is nice, super modern, right on the harbour, but the check-in process let it down so much that we would never return.

Our verdict on the Reykjavik EDITION
Watch the video on YouTube
Our video review, 2:15. Our own clips and photos are from October 2024, and the stock pictures are labelled.

The Reykjavik EDITION is Marriott’s luxury hotel on the old harbour in Reykjavík, right next to the Harpa concert hall. We stayed on the Saturday night of our Iceland trip in October 2024, after a morning at the south coast waterfalls, and it was the dearest night of the trip.

The hotel itself is nice. This review is mostly about what happened at the front desk, because it could happen to anyone who travels the way we do: on debit cards.

A dark glass and stone hotel with EDITION on its roof across a wide paved square, the glass front of Harpa on the right
Our photo, October 2024: the hotel from the square by Harpa.

Check-in: paid in full, then refused

We had paid for the room in full when we booked it on Booking.com: ISK 110,616, about £615. When we got to reception, they refused to let us check in without a credit card on file. We don’t travel with one, only travel debit cards, which is common.

We even offered to let them put a hold on a debit card for whatever they needed, around £800, but they refused and said it must be credit. It was an extremely awkward standoff. We would have been homeless that night if we hadn’t found a credit card, by luck, saved in Google Pay. Terrible service, and a very, very bad experience for a top hotel.

This is the review we left on Google:

I don’t rate this hotel at all, sadly. First, we travelled as usual with travel debit cards for currency conversion purposes, and they made it extremely awkward to check in, essentially refusing service unless a credit card is behind the lobby. Having a reserve is fine, and we asked to charge whatever is required (around 800 pounds) as a temporary hold to our debit card, but they refused, even though we had already paid our 600 pounds for the stay before even arriving. This essentially left us without accommodation, if it wasn’t for the fact we handily had Google Pay on us. What a horrible experience in a foreign country. Secondly, the rooms have AWFUL lighting, it’s so hard to see in there. This is most definitely not a five-star hotel in service, in my opinion.

Our Google review of the hotel
A long lounge under a wooden beamed ceiling, a black fireplace hanging over a live fire, white sofas and a wall lit green
Our photo, October 2024: the lobby lounge on the afternoon we arrived.

What the small print said

To be fair to the hotel, it was in writing. The small print of our Booking.com confirmation said: “Guests are required to show a photo identification and credit card upon check-in.” Nothing else warned us before we arrived, and the hotel’s Booking.com page still says the same today.

But the rest of the paperwork treats debit cards as normal:

  • Marriott, whose brand EDITION is, says in its own terms that at check-in the bank places a hold “on your debit or credit card” for the room and tax, any resort fee and an amount for incidentals, and that it can take up to five business days after you leave to be released.
  • Expedia’s listing for the same hotel says you may need photo ID and “a credit card, debit card or cash deposit” at check-in for incidental charges.
  • The hotel’s own menus say on every page that it takes credit cards, debit cards and contactless.

So the hotel will take a debit card for a drink, but it wouldn’t take ours for the hold. It doesn’t publish how much it holds. A blogger who stayed in 2022 had ISK 20,000 (about £122 today) charged to a credit card at check-in and refunded at the end. The hold we offered, around £800, was several times that (checked 15 November 2026).

Can you check into a hotel with a debit card?

Often you can, but not always, and you may only find out at the desk. What we would do now, whether you carry a UK travel debit card or a US debit card:

  • Carry one credit card, even if you’ve paid in full and never plan to spend on it. It’s what saved us.
  • Read the hotel’s policies on the booking site before you book, and look for the words “credit card upon check-in”.
  • If you only have debit cards, email the hotel before you go, ask whether it takes a debit card for the hold and how much the hold is, and keep the answer.
  • Allow for the hold. On a debit card it ties up real money until it is released, which Marriott says can take up to five business days after you leave.
  • Compare the booking sites’ small print. For this hotel, Expedia’s mentions debit cards and Booking.com’s doesn’t.

The hotel itself: modern and on the harbour

Once we were in, we could see the hotel itself is nice: super modern and right on the harbour. We had “fire and ice” cocktails for free on arrival at the lobby bar, pink with a thick white foam on top. We couldn’t find the hotel promising a welcome drink anywhere, so don’t count on one.

The lobby is a long lounge under a wooden beamed ceiling, with a black fireplace hanging over a live fire, white sofas, leather armchairs, a column of stacked lava stones and a wall washed in green light.

It is one of Marriott’s EDITION hotels: 253 rooms and suites, opened in autumn 2021, with interiors by the design firm Roman and Williams, and it holds one MICHELIN Key. Other guests score it 8.7 out of 10 on Booking.com (from 645 reviews, but 7.6 for value), 4.4 out of 5 on TripAdvisor and 9.4 out of 10 on Expedia (checked 15 November 2026).

A pink cocktail with a thick white foam top in a coupe on a black coaster on a white marble bar
Our photo, October 2024: our free fire and ice cocktail at the lobby bar.
The pink cocktail on the marble bar, a tall glass, a water glass and a card terminal behind it
Our photo, October 2024: the welcome drinks on the bar.
A tall column of stacked lava stones on a black sheepskin rug in a lobby with black sofas
Our photo, October 2024: the lava-stone column in the lobby.
Tiers of lit crystal decanters and rows of bottles above a white marble bar counter
Our photo, October 2024: the lobby bar.
A grey patrol ship, a red and white tug and a white boat at a wet quay under dark rain clouds
Our photo, October 2024: the harbour outside the hotel.
A white ship with a tall mast at a quay, a red hydrant, and a trawler and cranes across the old harbour
Our photo, October 2024: the quay by the hotel.

Our room: awful lighting

Ours was a Superior King Room with Courtyard View, 28 square metres: a big white bed, wooden walls, wall lamps, an armchair with a sheepskin, and a TV showing the hotel’s welcome screen.

But the rooms have AWFUL lighting. It was so hard to see in there. Our photos of the room the next morning are dark apart from the lit drinks shelf, and our video of the bathroom is almost black.

We weren’t the only ones. TripAdvisor’s summary of recent reviews mentions lighting problems and a gloomy feel, and a reviewer who stayed in October 2025 found the corridor lighting turned down frustratingly low. Not everyone agrees: a blogger who stayed in 2022 found their room bright.

A white double bed with a black bag on it, wall lamps and a pale wooden wall in a hotel room
Our video, October 2024: our Superior King room, with a courtyard view.
A wall TV showing the hotel’s welcome picture above a black bench
Our video, October 2024: the welcome screen on the TV.
A lit drinks shelf in a wooden niche, the rest of the hotel room dark around it
Our photo, October 2024: our room in the morning, dark apart from the drinks shelf.

The minibar

The drinks sit in a lit niche: Himbrimi Winterbird gin, a second spirit, a bottle of Barone Montalto Nero d’Avola, glasses, a corkscrew, a Nespresso machine with capsules, and Taylors tea. In the fridge were Red Bull, Pepsi, Peroni, a half bottle of Billecart-Salmon Brut Réserve champagne, a Pinot Grigio, Fever-Tree tonic, Icelandic Glacial water, kombucha, apple and mango juice and a ginger shot. The drawer had Pringles, Omnom chocolate, a Næra skyr snack, a Snickers, a Barebells protein bar, a birch-leaf face mask, a jar of lava salt and a travel adapter.

Nothing had a price on it in our photos, and we couldn’t find a minibar price list online. A guest in October 2025 had the Nespresso and the tea for free. Room service runs from 7am to midnight, and housekeeping comes twice a day (checked 15 November 2026).

A lit shelf with a bottle of gin, a bottle of red wine and glasses, tea, coffee capsules and a Nespresso machine below
Our photo, October 2024: the drinks shelf.
An open minibar fridge with Red Bull, juice, kombucha, tonic, Pepsi, a half bottle of champagne, Peroni and water
Our photo, October 2024: the minibar fridge.
A drawer of Pringles, Omnom chocolate, a skyr snack, a Snickers, a protein bar, a face mask and a jar of lava salt
Our photo, October 2024: the snack drawer.

The Roof, the rooftop bar

That night, after the Big Lebowski Bar and Skál!, we ended it at the hotel’s rooftop bar, The Roof. It was lively, with a nice atmosphere and a good view over the harbour.

Our bill came to 11,900 kr (about £66, or $87, at the time):

  • a glass of Bolla Pinot Grigio, 2,500 kr
  • a Barfluga, 1,800 kr
  • an espresso martini, 2,950 kr, plus a 900 kr “premium add”
  • a margarita, 2,850 kr, plus another 900 kr “premium add”

The Roof is on the 7th floor, all black inside so the view does the work, with glass doors onto a terrace that opens in season, and the hotel pitches it for the northern lights in winter. It is closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, and open 6pm to midnight on Wednesdays, Thursdays and Sundays, 6pm to 1am on Fridays and 1pm to 1am on Saturdays. Cocktails are 3,800 kr (about £23 / $31) on its June 2026 menu, which says prices include all taxes and service (checked 15 November 2026).

The old harbour at night from high up, lit buildings along the quay and gold reflections on the water
Our video, October 2024: the harbour from The Roof that night.
A bill from the hotel’s Roof Top bar in a black folder, a pen resting on it, total 11,900 kr
Our video, October 2024: our bill at The Roof, 11,900 kr.

TIDES, the lobby bar, Tölt and the spa

Everything else the hotel has (checked 15 November 2026):

  • TIDES, the main restaurant, with its own entrance on the harbour: Icelandic seafood and local meat, listed in the Michelin Guide. Breakfast 7am to 10.30am, lunch noon to 2.30pm and dinner 5.30pm to 10pm, every day, booked through Dineout.
  • Breakfast isn’t always in the rate: Booking.com charges about ISK 6,000 a person to add it, and the à la carte dishes are ISK 3,900 each.
  • The Lobby Bar, by the fire, every day from 11am to 11pm: cocktails ISK 3,200 to 3,690, draught beer ISK 1,900 to 2,400.
  • Tölt, a small hidden cocktail bar named after the Icelandic horse’s fourth gait, Thursday to Saturday, 6pm to 1am. A 2025 review says only suite guests and Marriott Bonvoy elite members get in, so ask.
  • The spa, with a hammam, steam room and sauna, every day from 10am to 8pm, over-18s only. Its own page lists ISK 4,350 for hotel guests, though a 2025 guest had it included in the destination fee. No swimming pool is listed.
  • Sunset, the basement nightclub, is listed as temporarily closed.
The hotel lounge in the morning, a black fireplace hanging over a live fire, leather and white armchairs and a green-lit wall
Our photo, October 2024: the lounge the next morning, empty.

What it costs now, and the resort fee

We paid ISK 110,616 for the night, about £615 then, in full when we booked. That included 11% VAT, ISK 666 city tax and a resort fee of ISK 5,950 a night. Today the fee is ISK 7,000 a night (about £43 / $57), paid at the hotel, plus the ISK 800 accommodation tax. A guest in October 2025 says it covered the spa and an ISK 7,000 food and drink credit at TIDES and TIDES Café, though not on the day you leave.

Booking.com prices for one night for two, room only, on Wednesday 18 and Saturday 21 November 2026 (we couldn’t tell whether the destination fee is included; checked 15 November 2026):

  • King Room, courtyard view (26 m²): ISK 82,800 midweek (£506 / $670), sold out on the Saturday.
  • Superior King Room with Courtyard View (ours, 28 m²): ISK 90,800 midweek (£555 / $735) and ISK 110,800 on the Saturday (£678 / $896), almost exactly what we paid.
  • Deluxe King Room with Scenic View (29 m²): ISK 102,800 midweek (£629 / $832) and ISK 122,800 on the Saturday (£751 / $994).
  • One-Bedroom Deluxe King Suite with Scenic View (54 m²): ISK 192,800 midweek (£1,179 / $1,560).

Parking at the EDITION

We had a hire car. When we asked on the day, the concierge offered valet parking at ISK 7,000 a night, or the Harpa car park under the concert hall next door at ISK 480 an hour or ISK 3,600 for 12 hours, paid at the machine or with the EasyPark app. Valet is still ISK 7,000 a night including tax (about £43 / $57), for 24 hours, and Expedia lists covered self-parking at ISK 6,800 a night. We couldn’t check Harpa’s prices today (checked 15 November 2026).

Getting there

The hotel is at Austurbakki 2, on the old harbour next to Harpa. It is about 45 minutes by car from Keflavík airport, and a taxi is about ISK 20,000 each way (£122 / $162). Check-in is from 3pm and check-out by 11am, and you must be 18 or over to stay.

Our tips

  • Carry a credit card, even if you’ve paid in full.
  • With only debit cards, email the hotel first and keep its answer.
  • Don’t count on a free welcome drink. We got one, but the hotel doesn’t promise it.
  • If good lighting matters to you, read recent reviews first. We weren’t the only ones who found it dark.
  • Finish a night at The Roof for the view, but not on a Monday or Tuesday, when it’s closed.
  • Check whether the ISK 7,000 destination fee is in your price or paid on arrival.
  • Ask about the Harpa car park next door if valet is too dear.

Reykjavik EDITION FAQ

Can I check into a hotel with a debit card? Often, but not always. The booking’s small print decides it: the Reykjavik EDITION’s Booking.com listing asks for a credit card, and the hotel wouldn’t take our debit card for the hold. Carry a credit card, or get the hotel’s answer in writing before you go.

Is the Reykjavik EDITION a Marriott hotel? Yes. EDITION is one of Marriott’s luxury brands.

Is the Reykjavik EDITION worth it? Not for us, after being refused at check-in on debit cards and sleeping in a room with awful lighting. If you carry a credit card you may enjoy it more: other guests score it 8.7 out of 10 on Booking.com.

Does the Reykjavik EDITION have parking? Yes. Valet parking is ISK 7,000 a night (checked 15 November 2026), Expedia lists self-parking at ISK 6,800, and the Harpa car park is next door.

Does the Reykjavik EDITION have a pool? No swimming pool is listed. The spa has a hammam, a steam room and a sauna.

Does the Reykjavik EDITION have room service? Yes, from 7am to midnight (checked 15 November 2026).

When did the Reykjavik EDITION open? In autumn 2021.

What is the Reykjavik EDITION destination fee? ISK 7,000 a night (about £43 / $57) in November 2026, paid at the hotel. Our 2024 booking had a resort fee of ISK 5,950 a night inside the price.

More from this trip

The EDITION was our Saturday night in Reykjavík, on our Iceland trip in October 2024. The rest of the trip: